Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the January Giveaway for a Trifox Carbon MTB Riser Handlebar


Shifting between first and second
#1
I'm a real novice at this so please make allowances! I was having trouble (front derailleur) shifting up from first to second. When I flicked the shift lever into 2nd, the cage would move across seemingly correctly, but the chain would struggle, make a lot of noise and refuse to shift up. If I pushed the shift lever over a little more - towards 3rd - and held it for a couple of seconds, the chain would move up on to 2nd position and stay there OK. I tried to correct this by increasing the tension a little on the shift wire. The result of that was that it shifts up to 2nd correctly, but won't go down to first. I thought, well OK, I must have over-tensioned it. So I released a tiny bit and retried - only to find I'd gone back to my initial position. I've been doing my head in, several times over increasing and reducing the tension, but I always end up with one problem or its opposite. What am I missing? Any help appreciated.
  Reply
#2
First, is this a recent occurrence, and if so, did it start after any type of maintenance or accident?

Secondly, the front derailleur must be properly positioned before adjusting - see http://www.parktool.com/blog/repair-help/front-derailleur-adjustments for full instructions on setting height and rotation as well as limits and cable "tension." If still a problem your derailleur may have developed play in the pivots.

You should also check the BB bearings to make sure they have no play.
  Reply
#3
I made the mistake of lending my bike to a friend. It was fine before that but when I got it back, I noticed the problem straightaway. He claimed he had no problem with it but something must have happened while it was in his care - I just don't know what.
  Reply
#4
(12-10-2014, 04:24 PM)colinmb Wrote:  I made the mistake of lending my bike to a friend. It was fine before that but when I got it back, I noticed the problem straightaway. He claimed he had no problem with it but something must have happened while it was in his care - I just don't know what.

If you feel comfortable doing this; it will result in the best possible performance.

Disconnect the front derailleur cable, and follow the instructions given in the link by our friend from Central NY State.

Make sure that you have the tools (including measurement tools) needed before you start.
Nigel
  Reply
#5
Thanks, Nigel. To the OP - possibly coincidence but also possible your friend accidentally tunked the derailleur with his foot or bumped against something. A slight rotation of the derailleur on the frame tube can easily degrade shifting, but best to go through the whole procedure for the best result. Make sure the derailleur clamp is firmly tightened once you get the position correct (don't gorilla it, though).
  Reply


Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Big Basso, Tiny Colnago
Today 02:43 PM
brakes
Today 02:21 PM
My Bicycle memories
Today 02:11 PM
Trifox carbon frames
Today 12:24 PM
Bicycle renovation suggestions.
Today 03:16 AM
2021 Pro Road Cycling
Yesterday 04:18 PM
Can someone identify this Bottom Bracket...
Yesterday 01:21 AM
11-42 cogs on Road bike?
01-24-2021 12:24 PM
NewBikeShopper (intro & opinion request)
01-20-2021 01:57 AM
1983 Trek 720
01-20-2021 12:23 AM

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Criminal
20 posts
no avatar 2. RollOn
5 posts
no avatar 3. Yevhen
5 posts
no avatar 4. NewBikeShopper
4 posts
no avatar 5. JoJoJo
4 posts