Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take Part in the October Giveaway to Win the Qiolor TIGER Retro Electric Bike


Grip Shifter Replacement
#1
Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able. I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur? I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5. On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
  Reply
#2
(09-07-2015, 02:11 PM)Barlong Wrote:  Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able.  I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur?  I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5.  On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
[quote pid='33835' dateline='1441649471']
Have you tried a local bike shop? I had to replace one a while back and my LBS had one in stock with a new brake cable attached to the grip.
[/quote]
"Where ever we go, there we are"
  Reply
#3
(09-07-2015, 09:50 PM)elmore leonard Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 02:11 PM)Barlong Wrote:  Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able.  I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur?  I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5.  On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
[quote pid='33835' dateline='1441649471']
Have you tried a local bike shop? I had to replace one a while back and my LBS had one in stock with a new brake cable attached to the grip.

[/quote]

(09-08-2015, 11:28 AM)Barlong Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 09:50 PM)elmore leonard Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 02:11 PM)Barlong Wrote:  Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able.  I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur?  I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5.  On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
[quote pid='33835' dateline='1441649471']
Have you tried a local bike shop? I had to replace one a while back and my LBS had one in stock with a new brake cable attached to the grip.

[/quote]
Yes, I found a bike shop open on labor day and they said they can get the part in a week and install for about $15 so I'm going to go ahead and let them do it and save some brain damage.
  Reply
#4
(09-08-2015, 11:28 AM)Barlong Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 09:50 PM)elmore leonard Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 02:11 PM)Barlong Wrote:  Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able.  I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur?  I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5.  On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
[quote pid='33835' dateline='1441649471']
Have you tried a local bike shop? I had to replace one a while back and my LBS had one in stock with a new brake cable attached to the grip.

(09-08-2015, 11:28 AM)Barlong Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 09:50 PM)elmore leonard Wrote:  
(09-07-2015, 02:11 PM)Barlong Wrote:  Let's start off by saying I'm not mechanically inclined but like to fix on my own when able.  I have, I'm guessing, a 15-20 year old 15 (3x5) speed Magna Outreach and the right 5 speed grip shifter (SRAM MRX 170-51) is broken internally and apparently 5 speed shifters are rare nowadays. My question is, will any shifter do or does it have to be compatible with the rear derailleur?  I currently have a Shimano SIS rear derailleur. The reason I ask is, the old shifter has gear 1 almost 180 degrees away from gear 5.  On the only 5 speed SRAM grip shifter I can find on the internet (SRAM MRX Comp), gears 1 through 5 are separated by only about 90 degrees, so either this new shifter has something internally to move the derailleur the same distance with less distance between the gears or I would need a derailleur that is more sensitive than the current one, correct?

Also it doesn't necessarily have to be a grip shifter. It's just for a college campus bike.

Thanks for any and all help.

Barry
[quote pid='33835' dateline='1441649471']
Have you tried a local bike shop? I had to replace one a while back and my LBS had one in stock with a new brake cable attached to the grip.

[/quote]
Yes, I found a bike shop open on labor day and they said they can get the part in a week and install for about $15 so I'm going to go ahead and let them do it and save some brain damage.
[/quote]
Smart move. You can't beat service like that. Plus you are supporting a local business. 
"Where ever we go, there we are"
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread
Author
Replies
Views
Last Post
 
2,345
09-03-2021, 11:15 AM
Last Post: Tollyboll123
 
3,123
08-02-2021, 07:23 AM
Last Post: Blank.Toogii
 
20,242
10-25-2014, 03:27 AM
Last Post: Daccordidavid
 
9,881
08-14-2014, 07:00 PM
Last Post: GeorgeET
 
26,312
08-23-2013, 02:17 AM
Last Post: Joe_W

Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Schwinn trike NOISE
Today 05:20 PM
Schwinn meridian rear drive axle
Today 04:36 PM
What was your first bicycle?
Yesterday 04:11 PM
Great UK Cycle Camping Map, For E-Bikes,...
Yesterday 05:38 AM
Charging at campground
Yesterday 05:33 AM
Failure to stop at stop sign means $500 ...
Yesterday 05:27 AM
Bicycle enthusiast located in California
Yesterday 04:15 AM
Moving in Style: Beyond Regular Transpor...
Yesterday 01:29 AM
Do you plan or random ride your MTB ride...
11-02-2024 11:43 AM
Cycling is Anti-Aging, But There's a Cat...
11-02-2024 11:36 AM

[-]
Join BikeRide on Strava
Feel free to join if you are on Strava: www.strava.com/clubs/bikeridecom

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
18 posts
no avatar 2. enkei
18 posts
no avatar 3. GirishH
13 posts
no avatar 4. Flowrider
12 posts
no avatar 5. Talha
10 posts