Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the June Giveaway for a brand new Merida Matts 6.5 bicycle

Compatibility of Components
I recently acquired an older mtn bike with a very light aluminum frame that has 8spd XTR shifters and derailleurs in good condition but with a trashed STX crankset and BB. I'm wondering if an '09 9spd XT crankset would work smoothly with an 8speed cassette and if so, what would be the best chain to use.

Sheldon brown says, that it could work

"Going the other direction, using wider chains with chainrings intended for narrower chains is not generally a major problem if there's only a one or two generation difference. The only problem you might run into is that the chain will be more liable to rub on the inside of the bigger chainrings in the small/small crossover gears, gears you shouldn't be using in any case. "

But: you have to look whether the BB / crank set matches the chain line of your front derailleur, other than that I see no problems. Use an 8speed chain, as the rear cassette will most probably not accept a 9spd one. Go for a good one, the cheap chains will be worn out quite fast, so you end up paying more, I think the HG70 is ok. Oh, and if you buy a new chain, go and get a new cassette.
I figured I'd need a new cassette. The question is which one? I read the compatibility info by Sheldon Brown, but it didn't quite clear it up for me. Can I use a 9-speed cassette with an 8 speed derailleur (and shifters)? If so, this would be ideal as I plan to upgrade to 9-speed shifters and different brakes down the road.

Well... Sheldon writes about "8 of 9", where you use 8sp shifters with 8 gears of a 9 sp cassette. I think this is not only difficult to set up correctly but also prone to automatic misadjustments, as the cable stretches, the RD gets knocked at etc. So I would not do this. If you want to upgrade, this is the time. Or next time, when you change chain and cassette. So if you don't want to invest the money in the new shifters at the moment, go for an 8sp cassette / chain and drive them some 1000 km. I think, the 30€ (or so) that you spend now on an 8sp drivetrain is money well spent, if that means you have less problems in the near future.

Thanks, Joe. I appreciate your input.


Possibly Related Threads...
Last Post
02-23-2018, 03:00 PM
Last Post: JFM
08-31-2015, 10:49 PM
Last Post: fthomas
10-08-2014, 05:18 AM
Last Post: daniel1988
12-14-2013, 09:55 AM
Last Post: 1FJEF
03-24-2013, 07:29 PM
Last Post: nfmisso
08-25-2012, 12:23 PM
Last Post: xerxes

Forum Jump:

10 Latest Posts
Merida Matts 6.5 Bicycle | June 2020
Today 06:24 PM
Clunk noise from front cogs
Today 01:42 PM
Help me identify my vintage Bridgestone ...
Today 12:34 PM
Rust on the handlebar
Today 10:41 AM
Bike front rim question replacement
Today 08:29 AM
Bike brand “Perfect”
Today 07:26 AM
BAGGI 1936(?)
Today 03:33 AM
Pedals: Clip vs. Clipless
Today 01:02 AM
first time biker
Yesterday 07:42 PM
Giant RS920 Bent Fork
Yesterday 07:16 PM

Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
25 posts
no avatar 2. CharleyFarley
19 posts
no avatar 3. Painkiller
14 posts
no avatar 4. Joe_W
13 posts
no avatar 5. Sagan97
10 posts