Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the January Giveaway for the DYU R1 20" City Electric Bike


FRONT DERALIEUR NOT WORKING
#1
Hi guys,

I have restored a 90' Fisher mountain bike. It works perfectly apart from the front derailleur. Gears goes down no problem. They go up from the first to second cog no problem but it is very difficult to make it go to the biggest gear. This is an old SRAM groupset.

It is not the cable tension, not the limit screws and not the position of the derailleur on the frame. These are the basic things I have checked. The chain is well oiled.
When turning the lever on the handlebar to go up from the second to the third front gear the derailleur move freely and swiftly, it gets stuck against the chain but still the chain is not going up!!!!!. I do not understand why.

Only if I go from the first to the third gear seems to work most times, but not always. it moves from first to second gear perfectly but not from second to third. What should I look at?
The derailleur position seems correct. above 1-2 mm from the biggest cog.

I am just wondering if the derailleur arm is bent (looks fine to me). I have tried with pliers to bend the arm cage so the the lower part is at an angle with the chain so that it can push it up but it did not improve. I can turn the lever on the handlebar so the arm pushes strongly against the chain but still the chain does not like to go up.

It is wired that it works fine from first to second. I have noticed that the derailleur arm cage has a different shape on its length and it touches different point when moving the chain from first- second in comparison to second-third. This is why I think there might be a problem with the cage although I cannot see anything evident.

Any suggestion will help. Thank you!

FM
  Reply
#2
The spring is worn and the derailleur needs replaced.

Front Derailleurs are very finicky and the springs seem to wear out so easily.

I've done away with all my 2x setups because I'm sick of dealing with them.
  Reply
#3
Hello, could you please add some photos? It would be useful to know which type of front derailleur is (top/high vs down/low pulling) and consider if it could be a problem related to the srping.
Can you say that the shifter is ok? Maybe it could be it the problem: it is more common that the internal mech give up rather than the spring of the front derailleur.
This kind of spring is very strong! [I've heard and seen brifters -even high quality shimano- broken due to the high friction caused by the cable and its housing poorly cleaned]
  Reply
#4
(09-14-2021, 03:27 PM)FabioMaria Wrote:  Hello, could you please add some photos? It would be useful to know which type of front derailleur is (top/high vs down/low pulling) and consider if it could be a problem related to the srping.
Can you say that the shifter is ok? Maybe it could be it the problem: it is more common that the internal mech give up rather than the spring of the front derailleur.
This kind of spring is very strong! [I've heard and seen brifters -even high quality shimano- broken due to the high friction caused by the cable and its housing poorly cleaned]

Agree on the strong spring unless rusted out. Never had a problem even on derailleurs over 40 yrs old; high end and cheaper (except the Simplex plastic/delrin models cracking). Sometimes worn/rusty pivot pins/bolts.
Ride Fast, Be Safe!
Howard
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads...

Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Aloha!
Today 05:19 AM
Question about Leg Shaving
Today 04:51 AM
Brand New Rusty Steel Split frame Bike
Today 04:36 AM
What was your first bicycle?
Yesterday 05:32 PM
paralyzed in a bike crash: Sports Illust...
Yesterday 02:54 PM
How much do you bike per year?
Yesterday 01:12 AM
Identify
01-15-2022 09:19 PM
Breaking in Brooks B17 Imperial
01-15-2022 03:42 PM
Big Basso, Tiny Colnago
01-15-2022 03:26 PM
ebikes and regular bikes
01-15-2022 03:15 PM

[-]
Join BikeRide on Strava
Feel free to join if you are on Strava: www.strava.com/clubs/bikeridecom

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
26 posts
no avatar 2. ReapThaWhirlwind
15 posts
no avatar 3. Jake1
14 posts
no avatar 4. jeffg
13 posts
no avatar 5. JR Namida
10 posts