Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the National Bike Safety Month giveaway for a RiderBag reflective backpack


One expensive lock vs two cheaper locks?
#1
Hi, I'm having trouble figuring out my best options for U-locks. What are your thoughts on one pricier lock from a reputable brand (e.g., this Kryponite KryptoLok Standard U-Lock with Cable for $47.09 with 20% off coupon) vs two less renowned locks (e.g., two of these Bell Catalyst 750 Long Shackle U-Locks for $39.58) ?

I was attracted to the Bell Catalyst partially based on lockpickinglawyer's review from a couple years ago - "I can't think of anywhere where you can get this much security for so little money".

Would it still be worth getting the one Kryptonite (or similar tier) lock over using two cheaper Bell locks? Am I cheaping out too much?

For reference, I plan on having my bike locked up all day while I'm at work (when we eventually return to the office), which will be in a satellite city of a large metropolitan area. Thanks in advance!
  Reply
#2
hey thanks for the video link! that's an impressive lock for such price -> especially for two locks, for the purpose of locking both wheels. i have Kryptonite Fahgettabouddit for urban use but of course it sits on much higher price tier with its 10/10 security rating.

what i honestly do not like about the Kryptonite lock that you have on the shortlist -> those cables are too weak for the city.

edit: Bell Catalyst 1 star reviews are not flattering and majority of the complaints are about the key jamming

- "The problem is when you try to remove the key... no matter how I turned it, it was completely stuck"
- Biggest issue noticed almost immediately is the lock mechanism gets stuck when turning the key to lock and unlock."
- "the key never consistently turned, always needed to be forced and eventually decided to quit"
- "The lock jammed after the 3rd use. Had to call a locksmith and pay $100 to get it cut off"
- "The lock is really difficult to use. The key does not turn smoothly. Rather, it binds while you're trying to turn it. It can take a lot of fidgeting to get this thing to work."
- "The lock pins jammed up after a few months. I was a little forceful with the key, but thats cuz it was sticking a lot due to getting wet."
- "I put the key in and out, I open and close the lock around 3 times until it stops working. Yes. Stops working completely. Won’t open, keys can come out but it’s a useless lock!"

and so on ...
  Reply
#3
Thanks for your insight. Those are some concerning reviews, but I guess that's just part of getting what you pay for.
  Reply
#4
The big question here for me is ... where will you lock the bike while at work? Is it gonna be on the street or in an office parking?
  Reply
#5
That's a fair question. To be honest, I'm not totally sure yet since we won't be moving to the new building until May. But I'm pretty sure it won't be on the street.
  Reply
#6
(04-04-2020, 08:38 PM)8jk8 Wrote:  That's a fair question. To be honest, I'm not totally sure yet since we won't be moving to the new building until May. But I'm pretty sure it won't be on the street.

That detail makes a difference in your decision (purchase) making. In my case, we have an underground parking where you can also leave a bike. It feels very safe, with surveillance. I still lock it with my Abus ultra 410 mini u-lock. I believe that it would be problematic to mess with your bike if it is parked someplace where people are passing by constantly .... and locked with those two Bell catalyst locks. Such as a parking spot next to the office building.
  Reply
#7
I hope you get to move into the new office in May.
I biked 80% of the time to my office the past year. My solution was to have a heavy 1/2" cable permanently locked to a stanchion in the stairwell (my "private" bike garage, I'm the only bike commuter). This way I didn't have to balance weight against security. I carry a lightweight cable lock on the bike at all times in case I stop at the store on the way home or something.
My point is, when you assess your new office, figure out if you can leave the lock/ cable/ chain/ whatever permanently installed. That will allow you to go heavier / bulkier in the trade-off between cost and weight.
Hope you find this to be useful advice.
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread
Author
Replies
Views
Last Post
 
961
08-15-2019, 05:11 PM
Last Post: wwwalterrr
 
7,409
12-04-2016, 02:03 AM
Last Post: Alexanderwhite
 
4,386
10-26-2014, 10:31 AM
Last Post: JanJ
 
16,833
08-02-2011, 04:08 AM
Last Post: lilybay

Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Saronni Colnago Critrium Frame set
Today 04:08 AM
Help me date this Rollfast
Today 03:11 AM
SmartHalo all-in-one biking accessory | ...
Today 02:25 AM
National Bike Safety Month | RiderBag Gi...
Yesterday 06:27 PM
CRESCENT PEPITA '72/'73
Yesterday 02:50 PM
Looking to purchase my 1st bike, which t...
Yesterday 09:50 AM
The Last Dance - ESPN
Yesterday 08:03 AM
Pinarello Dyodo ebike???? Review bad? Go...
Yesterday 07:48 AM
Lance - 30 for 30
05-26-2020 09:36 PM
CRESCENT PEPITA '72/'73
05-26-2020 11:23 AM

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
21 posts
no avatar 2. CharleyFarley
20 posts
no avatar 3. Criminal
15 posts
no avatar 4. Painkiller
13 posts
no avatar 5. JoJoJo
11 posts