Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the November Giveaway for the Fiido D11 folding sport e-bike


Poll: Madone 3.1 vs 4.5
Madone 3.1
Madone 4.5
 
 
Trek Madone 3.1 vs. 4.5
#1
I'm looking to purchase either a Madone 3.1 or 4.5. Does anyone have experience with both and could tell me if the 4.5 is worth the extra few hundred dollars?
Live life one century at a time.
  Reply
#2
I don't have any experience with Trek, but they are just like any other bikes. If you are dead set on choosing between those two, ride them both and see which one feels the best and go with it.

If you compared them on their web site, it appears that the main difference is in the carbon fiber as the technique in which they make the frame may be slightly different. The 4.5 is most likely a lighter weight bike than the 3.1, by how much, I don't know. Also, it appears that the forks are different as well. Both bikes have the 105 group. After riding the two, the difference in price would have to be your call, but if the 4.5 fits and rides better for you, it is worth the difference if you can afford it.
HCFR Cycling Team
Ride Safe...Ride Hard...Ride Daily
  Reply
#3
(07-26-2011, 09:43 PM)JohnV Wrote:  I don't have any experience with Trek, but they are just like any other bikes. If you are dead set on choosing between those two, ride them both and see which one feels the best and go with it.

If you compared them on their web site, it appears that the main difference is in the carbon fiber as the technique in which they make the frame may be slightly different. The 4.5 is most likely a lighter weight bike than the 3.1, by how much, I don't know. Also, it appears that the forks are different as well. Both bikes have the 105 group. After riding the two, the difference in price would have to be your call, but if the 4.5 fits and rides better for you, it is worth the difference if you can afford it.

I just noticed on the Trek website that the Madone 3.1 takes a rear bike rack. Yes, it's got a little bolt just above the rear derailleur hanger, but for the life of me, I can't figure out how you'd mount the struts to the carbon stays...unless you jerry-rigged some kind of clamping attachment. I'd LOVE to be able to mount my tank rack (JandD Expedition) to one of these carbon frames and use the bike everywhere.
  Reply


Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Please help me identify this old bicycle...
Today 11:36 AM
Seeking recommendations
Yesterday 06:18 PM
What is your dream cycling destination?
Yesterday 02:33 AM
LYGIE AND ATALA WINTER PROJECTS
11-30-2021 10:34 AM
Yet another bike ID thread (Pseudo-Batta...
11-30-2021 06:18 AM
Schwinn meridian fork replacement
11-30-2021 12:41 AM
Help! Trying to identify this bike
11-29-2021 07:20 PM
New Memeber
11-27-2021 06:51 PM
Budget Carbon Frames! ...who has bought...
11-26-2021 12:45 AM
Cycling motivation through the dark mont...
11-25-2021 06:28 PM

[-]
Join BikeRide on Strava
Feel free to join if you are on Strava: www.strava.com/clubs/bikeridecom

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. ReapThaWhirlwind
27 posts
no avatar 2. Jesper
18 posts
no avatar 3. jeffg
10 posts
no avatar 4. steven chen
6 posts
no avatar 5. Zviedrs
5 posts