Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take Part in the Latest Giveaway coming soon

Front deraileur... isn't... Throw the bike away?
Shortly after receiving the bike, a Schwinn ClearCreek <Target purchase>, the front derailleur stopped working (less than 50 miles on it, maybe 3 months ago). I gave up on it for a while and just kept the the chain on the second sprocket.

Around a month ago I decided that I really need to get it working. Since then, I've spent 20+ hours, broken several tools, and cut myself twice attempting to get this thing functional.

Right now it is as good as I have gotten it. I can go from '1' to '2' to '3', then from '3' to '2', but it won't return to '1'...

Time to add the bike to the bonfire?
Or take it to a good bike shop? Big Grin
Well, I wouldn't be throwing the thing in the bonfire just yet. I did look the bike up and it does appear that it is a dept store style bike, yes? Before getting rid of it, I may take it to a local bike shop and see what you think. Also look at the videos for derailleur adjustment on this site. My guess it that it may be a matter of adjusting your high and low screws, but it could also be the derailleur was defective to begin with. Or, you mentioned broken tools so it may have gotten broken in the process.

Did the bike come assembled? Remember that if you got it at Target/Wal-mart/etc., the mechanics there are probably not as well trained. Not to say they cannot set up a bike or bad workers, but they may not know as much as someone that works at a local shop. It could be the part is defective or that the cables are not working properly.

Here is an interesting link from Sheldon Brown, an old bike guru about department store bikes:http://www.sheldonbrown.com/gloss_da-o.html#department

So, at 50 miles, you may be nearing that mark. But, it does not mean without a little adjustment here and an inexpensive used, quality part there, it cannot be a decent bike.

Good luck.
A frequently neglected area of setting up the fd is the height above the top ring, this needs to be as close as pos without fouling, the alignment is also critical, especially on shaped plates.

I set this up with the cable disconnected and use a short piece of wire to pull it manually whilst rotating the pedals, having confirmed all functions operate properly, re connect the cable from the shifters and tauten the cable and adjust the shifters as required.

A work stand is useful, but a substitute is a noose hanging from the garage roof into which you can slot the saddle, if you set it so the front wheel is on the ground, the bike won't swing around too much.

And in any case, this should be covered by warranty, try giving your supplier a ring and complain, they should tell you to get if fixed at a lbs and send them the bill.
This <s>might be</s> is almost certainly more hassle than it's worth in this case, but if all else fails you could get some friction shifters. You can read about friction shifting and why you might consider it here http://www.rivbike.com/article/components/shifting .

To my thinking, once it's straight and at the right height, the front derailer is about the simplest component on your bike--it's just a cage that moves the chain left or right. The thing is, indexing your shifts for two or three big chain-rings with that simple mechanism seems kinda unnecessary. In contrast, friction shifting works really well in front and is super easy to do. You can get cheap but effective thumb shifters from Rivendell http://www.rivbike.com/products/show/sunrace-thumb-shifters/17-097 or Velo-Orange http://www.velo-orange.com/fafrthsh.html .

Of course this means removing the twist shifters and replacing your grips (cuza the short ones necessitated by twist shifting).

The other problem is that if you want to retain indexed shifting over the rear cogs, you would have to live with mismatching shifters and grip setup between the left and right sides of your bars. Again, I would only do this if you really want to keep the bike and find no other recourse in the previous suggestions.

Possibly Related Threads...

Forum Jump:

10 Latest Posts
What is your dream cycling destination?
Yesterday 01:39 PM
2010 Specialized Hardrock
Yesterday 05:54 AM
04-22-2024 02:04 PM
How much do you bike per year?
04-22-2024 01:35 PM
Christmas presents for cycling
04-22-2024 01:31 PM
04-22-2024 01:26 PM
Do you have a four foot rule?
04-22-2024 01:12 PM
Fat bikes for ever..
04-22-2024 12:23 PM
Rear hub issue
04-21-2024 09:01 PM
Lectric One
04-17-2024 09:58 PM

Join BikeRide on Strava
Feel free to join if you are on Strava: www.strava.com/clubs/bikeridecom

Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
28 posts
no avatar 2. enkei
25 posts
no avatar 3. GirishH
15 posts
no avatar 4. meamoantonio
13 posts
no avatar 5. Frankly
12 posts