Have questions or want to discuss cycling? Join Now or Sign In to participate in the BikeRide community.

New: Take part in the May Giveaway for a Road Electric Bike Hurricane from KBO


Why caliper brakes on road bikes?
#1
Guys,

Why do road bikes always seem to come equipped with caliper brakes (either centre or side pull), yet MTBs have the cantilever style brake? Is it perhaps due to weight?

Dave M, I'm pretty sure you'll know this one Smile.
  Reply
#2
Good question, I'll give it a shot. I think the main reason is weight and their small size. However, some road bikes these days are using cantilever and disc brakes. You won't see v-brakes on a road bike because road levers don't pull enough cable for them.
  Reply
#3
Hi Alex,

Hey quick response! I forgot about disc brakes because my bike is a ten-year-older - 1999 Kona Caldera but still going strong!

For road bikes I know it is important to keep the weight down: well also for MTBs mine weighs in at 27lb with a steel frame (I'm sure the Al frames these days weigh a lot less but maybe a little too ridgy).

I can't really see that there be much difference in weight between the brake types but all counts on a road bike. Just curious as to why this seems to be the (until recently, as you said), the norm...
  Reply
#4
Well if you're going to thrown down the gauntlet, I suppose I HAVE to reply...
I'm sure I don't know the whole history but I'd say:
1. tradition - calipers was the first design that performed well and designers have stayed with them (there was some really goofy designs in the 1800's)
2. simplicity/interchangeability - easier to install and adjust
3. cheaper - when you include the extra frame work required for posts, they're probably a fair bit cheaper
4. more aero
5. they're strong enough - if you can skid the wheel or flip the bike, you don't need stronger brakes anyway
6. lighter - this is probably true if you include the frame posts and the extra strength the frame needs to handle the brake stress with cantis

Can't think of anything else. Some of the reasons for switching to cantis was to give clearance for bigger tires and to allow for better shedding of mud. Those are some of the reasons touring and cyclocross bike have them. Can anyone think of anything else?
  Reply
#5
Yeah, I think people got most of the arguments down. Simpler design means less trouble with them, easier to work on, and so forth. Very light as well. Very easy to find parts for, unless it's a bevel pad setup like I used to have on an old junker MTB I owned where you have to struggle for parts.
Why is it that they make adult bikes that'll generally work for 5'9" or above, yet when you pedal these same bikes they only work for someone who is 5'4" or so?
  Reply
#6
Also, the one bolt design allows for hot swapping during races. V-brakes, canti's etc., all require a post on either side. Calipers don't. One bolt off, slip off old brake, slide on new brake, re tighten. I actually saw a mechanic hanging out a support vehicle window swapping a front brake so the rider didn't have to stop.
Dedicated scholar of bicycles
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread
Author
Replies
Views
Last Post
 
Guest
10,359
08-03-2008, 08:12 AM
Last Post: Aushiker

Forum Jump:

[-]
10 Latest Posts
Which gravel bike saddle do you suggest?
Yesterday 08:58 PM
2018 Specialized Stumpjumper Comp Alloy ...
Yesterday 01:06 PM
Biking in the rain
Yesterday 12:49 PM
Looking for a fixed gear bike under $300
Yesterday 12:44 PM
Have you Ever Tried an Electric Bike?
Yesterday 12:40 PM
2021 Pro Road Cycling
Yesterday 05:10 AM
Trek 720 (1997) Drive Train (Crank & Der...
05-11-2021 06:05 PM
I think I might of been a little too has...
05-11-2021 02:03 AM
Schwinn 3rd Avenue 700C hybrid
05-08-2021 02:33 AM
Square-Taper BB 68 (1.37 24T) Crank-Arm ...
05-07-2021 01:52 PM

[-]
Top 5 Posters This Month
no avatar 1. Jesper
28 posts
no avatar 2. ChaseCal
6 posts
no avatar 3. Papa Dom
4 posts
no avatar 4. ManBearPig
4 posts
no avatar 5. Stephen111
4 posts